Close up of person with a hand cast

Product Liability Basics: When a Defective Product Causes Harm

Defective products can be more than an inconvenience—they can cause serious injuries or even death. When a consumer is harmed by a product, understanding product liability law is essential to protect legal rights and pursue compensation. In Pennsylvania, product liability claims can involve manufacturers, distributors, and retailers, depending on the circumstances of the injury. Knowing the basics of how these claims work helps victims take the right steps after an accident.

Understanding Product Liability

Product liability refers to the legal responsibility that manufacturers, distributors, and sellers have for placing a defective product into the hands of consumers. If a product is defective and causes harm, the injured party may be entitled to compensation. These cases are not about blaming the consumer for using the product incorrectly; they focus on whether the product was unreasonably dangerous when it left the manufacturer’s control.

In Pennsylvania, product liability claims are typically based on three types of defects: design defects, manufacturing defects, and marketing defects. Each type carries its own legal considerations and challenges.

Design Defects

A design defect occurs when a product is inherently unsafe because of the way it was designed, even if it was manufactured correctly. These defects exist before the product is ever made and affect the entire line of products. An example could be a power tool that is prone to overheating and igniting, even when used as directed. Proving a design defect often requires expert testimony to show that a safer, feasible alternative design was available but not used.

Manufacturing Defects

Manufacturing defects happen when a product is made incorrectly, deviating from the intended design. These defects can affect a single item or a limited batch. For instance, a batch of prescription medication might contain the wrong dosage due to a factory error, causing serious side effects. Manufacturing defect claims are often easier to prove than design defects because the focus is on a specific item rather than the entire product line.

Marketing Defects or Failure to Warn

Products must include adequate warnings and instructions for safe use. A failure to warn occurs when the manufacturer or seller does not provide sufficient information about potential risks. For example, a cleaning product that contains harmful chemicals must include clear instructions and caution labels. If someone is injured because they were not warned about a known risk, a marketing defect claim may be valid.

Who Can Be Held Liable

In Pennsylvania, multiple parties may be liable for a defective product. This can include the manufacturer, distributor, retailer, or even a wholesaler. Liability is not limited to the company that made the product; anyone in the supply chain who placed the defective product into commerce can be held responsible. Determining who is liable often requires investigation into the product’s journey from manufacture to the point of sale.

Establishing Liability in Pennsylvania

To succeed in a product liability case in Pennsylvania, the injured party must prove that the product was defective, that the defect caused the injury, and that they suffered actual damages. Evidence may include the defective product itself, photographs of the injury, medical records, and documentation of how the product was used. Expert witnesses are often crucial in these cases to explain why a product is unsafe or how the defect caused the harm.

Unlike some states, Pennsylvania applies a strict liability standard for product liability cases. This means that the plaintiff does not have to prove that the manufacturer was negligent. If a product is defective and causes injury, the manufacturer can be held responsible, regardless of the care taken during production. However, negligence claims may also be brought in certain circumstances, particularly if there is evidence that the company ignored known risks or failed to follow industry standards.

Common Examples of Product Liability Cases

Product liability claims can arise from a wide range of products. Some common examples include:

  • Household appliances that overheat or catch fire

  • Power tools or machinery with dangerous moving parts

  • Prescription medications or medical devices with harmful side effects

  • Children’s toys with small parts that pose choking hazards

  • Automotive defects that lead to accidents or malfunctions

  • Food products contaminated with harmful bacteria

Each type of product presents unique challenges for proving liability, but the underlying principle remains the same: the injured party must show that a defect existed and directly caused harm.

Steps to Take if Injured by a Defective Product

If you are harmed by a defective product, taking immediate and deliberate steps can protect your legal rights and strengthen your case.

  • Seek Medical Attention
    Your health is the top priority. Get treatment for injuries as soon as possible and follow your doctor’s recommendations. Medical records will also serve as important evidence in your claim.

  • Preserve the Product
    Keep the defective product in its current condition. Do not try to repair or alter it. Photographs of the product, packaging, and any labels can also be useful.

  • Document the Incident
    Write down details about how the injury occurred, including the time, location, and circumstances. If there were witnesses, collect their contact information and statements.

  • Report the Incident
    Notify the retailer or manufacturer of the injury. In some cases, you may also need to report certain defects to government agencies, such as the Consumer Product Safety Commission.

  • Contact a Product Liability Attorney
    A personal injury lawyer can review your case, identify liable parties, and guide you through the legal process. Time limits, or statutes of limitations, apply to product liability claims in Pennsylvania, so early action is critical.

Compensation Available in Product Liability Cases

Victims of defective products may be entitled to several types of compensation. Common damages include:

  • Medical expenses related to treatment and ongoing care

  • Lost wages due to time off work or reduced earning capacity

  • Pain and suffering for physical and emotional distress

  • Property damage if the defective product caused loss or damage to personal property

In severe cases, punitive damages may also be awarded to punish a manufacturer or seller for egregious misconduct. A lawyer can help determine the appropriate types and amounts of compensation for your specific situation.

Challenges in Product Liability Cases

Product liability cases can be complex. Companies often have legal teams ready to dispute claims, and establishing the exact cause of an injury may require scientific or technical evidence. Additionally, identifying all potentially liable parties in the supply chain can be difficult. Despite these challenges, careful documentation, expert testimony, and legal guidance increase the likelihood of a successful claim.

Conclusion

Understanding product liability is important for anyone who has been injured by a defective product. Pennsylvania law provides avenues for victims to seek compensation from manufacturers, distributors, and sellers. If you have suffered an injury, acting quickly, preserving evidence, and seeking legal counsel can protect your rights. Product liability cases can be complicated, but with the right approach, injured consumers can hold responsible parties accountable and recover damages for their losses.